You will be redirected to the website of our parent company, Schönherr Rechtsanwälte GmbH: www.schoenherr.eu
Until recently, a "dupe" was a cheaper alternative that shoppers discovered by chance, entailing considerable effort on the part of infringers to keep abreast of fashion trends. Today it can be generated on demand. Artificial intelligence can now quickly scan runway shows, social media and sales data to identify a handbag, a shoe or a fragrance bottle worth copying.
This structural shift in how imitations are produced may require a reassessment of how enforcement needs to respond and a recalibration of the traditional legal toolkit for the modern age.
From dupe culture to dupe automation
Unlike a mere counterfeit good, a dupe relies on unfair competition and parasitism, without being an obvious infringement of intellectual property rights. From the infringer's perspective, the reasoning remains unchanged: consumers seek the aesthetic appeal of a desirable product without having to pay its premium price. It is precisely this tension that is making dupes increasingly attractive and commercially successful, namely they promise access to the "luxury element" of the real product while offering an inexpensive, low-value substitute for the original.
The large-scale implementation of AI has fundamentally changed how IP infringement is carried out. Fast-fashion platforms now use proprietary algorithms to continuously scan social media, designer portfolios and competitor sites for trending silhouettes and viral aesthetics, sending outputs directly into production. This can compress a copying cycle that once took months into a matter of days. More broadly, AI has made it easier to launch a brand (lowering most barriers in this respect), turning an idea and a few prompts into designs and marketing content.
Beyond product design, the same generative capability is now being directed at brand imagery itself. Practitioners in the luxury sector report a rise in synthetic marketing materials used to promote counterfeit sales, including convincing product photography, storefronts and even fabricated influencer endorsements, all created without any genuine product ever existing.
This practice, alongside small variations to packaging colours or typography, aims at evading automated monitoring filters.
The numbers behind the trend
The scale of the underlying problem is already well documented by the EU's own institutions, before AI is even factored into the picture. According to a study[1] published by the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) in January 2024, counterfeiting in the clothing, cosmetics and toy sectors cost EU industries close to EUR 16bln in lost annual sales and nearly 200,000 jobs, based on annual averages for the period 2018–2021. The clothing sector bore the largest share, at close to EUR 12bln, representing 5.2 % of the sector's EU turnover, while cosmetics lost close to EUR 3bln.
While these figures predate the current wave of AI-driven design scraping and image generation, a storm may be brewing on the horizon. Since generative tools make it cheaper and faster to imitate a look without imitating a trademark, the true scale of AI-accelerated imitation in fashion and luxury is likely understated by statistics built for an earlier generation of copying.
Redesigning the playbook
Traditional enforcement against lookalikes relies primarily on the likelihood of confusion test, which examines whether a third party's sign is sufficiently similar to a trademark in relation to similar goods or services is likely to mislead consumers as to its origin. AI-generated dupes are often deliberately engineered to sit just outside that test. They avoid this by borrowing only the product's silhouette or alluding to its likeness.
One example of Romanian case law[2] illustrates a similar dynamic. In a dispute over closely imitated packaging, the High Court of Cassation and Justice found no unfair competition where the products carried clearly different brand names, and noted that a consumer who knowingly buys a cheaper, non-original alternative at a lower price is simply engaging in lawful competition on price and quality, rather than being deceived. When imitation is deliberate but not deceptive, confusion-based claims may fail. AI has made that kind of imitation cheap and fast to produce at scale.
In short, it is not solely the sheer similarity brought on by the dupe, but also the overwhelming volume of content generated within a very short period of time.
As such, one alternative for luxury and premium fashion brands may rely on reputation-based protection. Under Article 9(2)(c) of Regulation (EU) 2017/1001, as mirrored in Romania under Article 39(2)(c) of Law No. 84/1998, the owner of a reputed trademark may take action against use that take unfair advantage of, or is detrimental to, the trademark's distinctive character or repute, without having to prove a likelihood of consumer confusion. The Court of Justice of the European Union has described this practice as "free-riding", whereby a third party attempts to benefit from the power of attraction and prestige of a reputed trademark without paying for or investing in it. Nevertheless, a case-by-case assessment should be taken into consideration.
What this means for the fashion and luxury market
While trademarks remain the foundation, names and logos alone will not stop AI-generated dupes. A holistic approach should be considered, combining careful management of the IP rights portfolio with monitoring and proactive enforcement.
For this reason, the filing strategy should anticipate AI-accelerated copying. For capsule collections, collaborations and any product likely to trend, speed and preliminary assessment is key. Clearing and filing trademark and design applications before launch, rather than after a dupe appears, may help narrow the gap.
A layered approach is essential within this fast-paced and constantly evolving segment, leaving no room for being fashionably late.
[1] EUIPO, "Economic impact of counterfeiting in the clothing, cosmetics, and toy sectors in the EU", 15 January 2024 - https://www.euipo.europa.eu/en/publications/clothing-cosmetics-and-toy-sectors-in-the-eu-2024
[2] Decision No. 2108/2016, First Civil Chamber of the High Court of Cassation and Justice, 4 November 2016
Authors: Tiberiu Protopopescu, Yoana Strateva
Tiberiu
Protopopescu
Senior Attorney at Law
romania